My comment reply to a comment by a well-meaning American Christian capitalist; on my recent blog on being at war with the (UK) government. I have adapted the text. The government takes care of everyone and controls society and industry. Isn't that socialism? Well, it is certainly not American capitalism or indeed, any other kind of capitalism. Although capitalism does attempt to control “everyone, society and industry,” it can hardly be said to take care of anyone at all, now can it? What we have in the UK is a government supportive of and controlled by the concerns of big business. Words are cheap. One thing this government is not, is socialist. The present crowd of lick-spittle opportunists call themselves the Labour Party but the last thing they concern themselves about, unless it affects their masters’ profits, is the labour force. My taxes are going to profit mongers not to the needs of the people.
I am in rebellion against a puppet regime of corporations. What we have in the UK is benign fascism. In America, you have a more overt version of less benign fascism but that is to some extent an aside. Americans are more in your face about things and so what their government actually is is more overt. The British government is no different in essence. They just don’t shout about it.
There are many version hawked about of what is called socialism, much of expounded falsely by opponents as what I would call “social fascism”. The Nazis called themselves socialist as Pol Pot did and even the religious dictatorship in North Korea. That no more makes them socialist than the Inquisition calling itself a Christian organization made it so.
Socialism is where the people run government and control expenditure and taxation. A truly socialist government is not the ultimate power but the servant of the people. The means of production, distribution and exchange, basically, heavy industries, the infrastructure, essential services and finance are no longer owned privately by corporations and run for their ultimate benefit alone; but is universally of the people, and run by the people and for the people. The government is vigorously controlled as to what it can do without the direct permission of the people. You merely have the typical American conservative middle-class Christian fear of what you think is socialism. You probably think it godless. Maybe you think they will force your daughters into free love associations with Party members, so to speak; take possession of your house for use an official lackey’s Dacha; and burn down your church None of these is advocated by socialism. Socialism is an alternative system of social organisation and property ownership. It is not the spawn of Satan, although capitalism just may be.
The first organized socialists in near modern Europe were bible believing Christians. For example, see Gerald Winstanley and the Levellers of the Stuart revolutionary period. They got all their views on the dignity and total equality of human worth from the bible. Socialism sprang from Christianity. Christian socialism thrived in the UK during the 20th century and many socialists today are so because their Christian beliefs allow them no option. That Marxist-Leninism went off the rails under Czar Stalin the First and hopefully last, does not mean the principles of socialism are false. That would be like dismissing Christianity because of the lunatic Calvinist fringe today or the Inquisition and the Witch Finder Generals.
I'm tired of exchanging views on socialism with American Christians. On a whole, they equate capitalism with their religion; and socialism with Stalinism. One hardly ever sees that amongst European Christians any more, except amongst the verbose but relatively minor literalist lunatic fringes.
My two passions, Christian spirituality and socialism are to such as you, a dichotomy that never the twain can meet. Well, they have met in me. So return to the puppet Obama that Americans are wetting their knickers over at the moment like adolescent girly fans. Let's see in this four years just how much Obama changes. Nothing of note I'll warrant and the corporations will still own you.
Yours is a system of no change except the figurehead party. Tweedle Dum or Tweedle Dee. Well, it seems that Dum had just departed to a corporation directorship for Daddy. Dee has more charisma which means nothing outside the personality obsessed backwoods that America often appears to be.
I no longer hold out any hope for America to take the lead for improving human society. It seems Western Europe must go it alone and probably fail due to numerous factors, primarily that of hostile financial powers who run whole countries. Jack London’s analysis of the intensity and drawn-out struggle ahead for humanity, as shared in The Iron Heel, is spot on.
Nothing personal, I just took the opportunity to spleen my vent. |